Skip to main content
The Dairy Wagon

The Gold Standard in Milk.

The Service to Match.

Family-run dairy supplier delivering
farm-fresh products and café essentials
across NYC and New Jersey.

Carrying NYC's Coffee Scene on Our Wagon Since 2009.

In 2009, we loaded our first delivery into a single pickup truck, just as specialty coffee was starting to take hold in New York. Over the years that followed, we watched the city’s coffee scene grow into one of the best in the world, and we grew right alongside it. Today, The Dairy Wagon supplies cafés across NYC and New Jersey with premium farm-fresh dairy and the essentials that keep their counters running. We’re proud to have played a small part in the city’s coffee boom, one delivery at a time.

Farm Fresh. Nothing in between

WHAT SETS THE WAGON APART

glove

WHITE GLOVE SERVICE

clock icon

5:00 PM CUTOFF TIME FOR NEXT DAY DELIVERY

milk icon

AWARD WINNING MILK

family owned icon

FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED

WHAT SETS THE WAGON APART

glove

WHITE GLOVE SERVICE

clock icon

5:00 PM CUTOFF TIME FOR NEXT DAY DELIVERY

milk icon

AWARD WINNING MILK

family owned icon

FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED

Battenkill products

WHY BATTENKILL

Ask anyone in New York’s coffee scene about Battenkill, and you’ll hear the same two words: award-winning. Baristas say it, café owners say it, and almost none of them will switch. But what did it actually win? And why do people swear by it? I decided to find out for myself.

I started where anyone would, with a search. The news coverage was easy to find. In 2010, Battenkill became the first farmer-producer-bottler in New York State to be named Highest Quality Milk. That was impressive, but I wanted to know whether it was a one-time win.

It wasn’t. In 2014 they placed second with a 99.2, two-tenths of a point behind first. Two years later, in 2016, they took the top spot again, with a perfect score of 100. No other milk in the state competition earned a perfect score.

That raised a bigger question for me. A perfect score based on what? What was the methodological process that led to this conclusion? I went looking for the published results and a breakdown of how the milk was tested. I came up empty every time. So... I went straight to the source. I found the contact list for Cornell’s dairy testing program and sent an email asking for the official results.

Less than an hour later, someone close to the testing replied: “The results from the state fair testing are not public; only the names of the winners for each category are released each year. I can tell you that the results are based on rigorous microbiological, chemical, and flavor testing throughout shelf-life.”

That last part changed how I saw the award. They weren’t judging the milk on the day it was bottled. They were judging how it held up days later, sitting in a café’s fridge, waiting for its turn under the steam wand. Suddenly the question of why baristas refuse to switch answered itself. The quality doesn’t fade by Thursday.

The McEachron family has farmed in Washington County for over a century. They grow the feed for their own herd and bottle every drop right on the farm, the same day it’s milked. No middleman, no long trip to a processing plant. Just a farm that controls every step. So when people call Battenkill award-winning, they’re not just repeating a headline. They’re describing what they see in their own fridge.

The best service is the kind you only notice when you need it.

Most of our customers rarely see us, and that’s by design. By the time the first espresso is pulled, the fridge is already stocked and the milk has been rotated so the earliest dates are up front. It’s the kind of delivery you stop thinking about, which is exactly how it should be.

On the rare morning when something isn’t quite right, you won’t be left waiting on a callback. You’ll reach someone who knows your account, and it will be taken care of before the day is out.

Pixalated milk man

Your morning rush doesn’t have time for a support ticket

BRANDS WE’RE PROUD TO CARRY

argyle-logo
barista-logo
battenkill-logo
califia-logo
dona-logo
harney-logo
kriemhild-dairy-logo
kutiks_logo
mapleland-logo
mcmurry-logo
milkadamia-logo
minor-logo
monin-logo
nounos-logo
oatly-logo
saratoga-logo
tenzo-logo